SN 2x05 Simon Said

[exsequar]

I *love* our show. I really do.

I was clutching and leaping on Michelle - I'm sorry baby, I know you're sick, I shouldn't have done that! I just can't help myself! The things these boys DO to me.


I LOVE ASH. "Well hell, I guess I need pants then". TOO PERFECT OMG *draws a zillion hearts* I love that Sam couldnt get Ash to come out, but Dean got the workings of Ash's bizarre mind and knew to call him DR BADASS. I just love Ash with all my tiny little heart.

I love Andy. He's adorable and a bit of a dork but he's just HAPPY with the little things and man he's a sweetheart. Awww. I hope we see him back again.

I like Jo. Much more than I did after ELAC. She had a bit of sassy spunk to her this episode ("I guess you'll be taking a truck nap!" and "...and I'm fine") and also her crush on Dean is adorably inept. Oh god the music. I liked her quite a bit this ep, and I'm GLAD, because it's not like I WANT to hate part of this show. Sam/Dean will forever and always be true to me, regardless of who else they throw in, so I'd rather LIKE who they do throw in, ya know?

I love Dean supporting Sam with his visions. I love "You've always been a freak *thighslap*". I love Dean's hand resting comfortingly on Sam's back as Sam angsts about the doctor getting smooshed - it's on Sam for the whole time the camera's panning towards them, and he only slides it off as they start talking. It's just the sweetest thing. (HUG ALREADY DAMMIT)

I love all the geeky Star Wars references. AWESOMECAKES.

I love Dean cheerfully giving up the Impala. Cracked my shit UP.

I like the tweaks to the mythology. Still not sure exactly where they're headed, but I'm very intrigued!

I am amused by the blatant twincest. "THEY SPLIT US UP! *angstyemocakes*"

I liked this episode a whole lot. Good stuff, Ben Edlund! *salutes*


So this season, this is how I order the episodes from favorite to least favorite thus far.

1. 203 Bloodlust
2. 201 In My Time of Dying
3. 205 Simon Said
4. 202 Everybody Loves a Clown
5. 204 CSPWDT

How about you guys?

Comments

[black-regalia.livejournal.com]

I agree with you completely on your ratings! That is, in fact, the exact order I would place it.

Mebbe 2x01 would tie with 2x05...It's hard to say. If I were an honest woman, I would say 2x01 before 2x05, just like you, but the Sammy angst claws at my little fangirl heart.

...

No, no. I will stay good. Your listing exactly.

[indilime.livejournal.com]

I love Andy. He's adorable and a bit of a dork but he's just HAPPY with the little things and man he's a sweetheart. Awww. I hope we see him back again.

FOR SERIOUS. I love when Sam was telling him he could have anything he wanted, and he was just like, but I have everything I need. LOVE.

[calicokat.livejournal.com]

There was one line in there when he was trying to rape the girl and he said...something about like "He's my family" and something something and it was supposed to be a serious scene but it was so blatantly twincesty I cracked up.

All the scenes where Dean got his mind controlled were "Squee!"

I agree, too, much more with the liking Jo this episode.

Dean/Ash. DESTINED LOVERS. ... *ahem*

[silver-sunn101.livejournal.com]

Even my 15-year-old brother noticed the blatant twincest between Andy and his brother. SO OBVIOUS.

Both of us were hoping that Andy would join Sam and Dean, but nooooo. They just leave him behind. He's such a sweet/dorky/cool character! I want him to come back. Like... now. Please?

The Star Wars references had me cracking up. And Dean giving up the Impala so easily. I thought he was going to kill Andy after he realized what he'd done ^_^

*cough* I really AM on a hiatus. I just can't stay away from LJ. I wish I could quit you, LJ!

[weasleytook.livejournal.com]

Dean. Singing.

That's all I can even muster right now because I'm so joyful.

(Well that, and OMG THEY PLAYED A SPINAL TAP SONG.)

Season 2 is basically rocking like craaaaaaaazy.

[riverdresses.livejournal.com]

Ash was ROCKING LIKE DEAN TONIGHT. (or, maybe not as much, but pretty damn close! :D) I think your love for him is starting to rub off on me, Anne! XD

I still can't stand Jo, but . . . I could come around? Maybe?

*squees for the obvious twincest* SO FUCKING GLAD I'M NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO SAW IT! (you'd have to be blind not to!)

*squees for the Wincest and Dean singing* The thighslapping? YAY! :D

[nanakomatsu.livejournal.com]

Omg dean singing *___*
Ok, I'll stop now, I can do it XD ....couldn't agree more about everything!!! even if I'm not so sure about Jo yet. I'll see :)
About the order, almost the same for me... Maybe I'd chance just 4. 204 CSPWDT and 5. 202 Everybody Loves a Clown.
I can't wait for next week!!!! ;)

[nightchik.livejournal.com]

Okay, HARD.

I loved the 1st ep, but then they only seemed to get better, so... UM. Favorite moments vs. overall makes it impossible too. Here's what I got at the moment, but don't quote me on this.

1. 2.02 - for the angst and the girls, but, um, I forwarded through the boring clown parts. Dean got punched in the face! Not the strongest overall, but it had lots of great moments, even if some are too painful to speak of ever again!
2. 2.03 - CRAZY HUNTERS. HOTNESS.
3. 2.01 - SNIFF. Mythology moving forward! Sort of. Ghost dean! Whee.
4. 2.05 - Brothers who LOVE EACH OTHER! Dean SINGING! FREAK SAMMY!!1!
5. 2.04 - Though it did have the HARDCORE SEX and DEAN CRYING, so I dunno.

[redbrickrose.livejournal.com]

*loves*

I like Jo a lot too, and I think she's just going to get better. Which is a good thing, you're right, because whoever they put with either of the boys had better be cool. But I actually trust the writers to know that. (And you know, back in my X-Files days I never thought I'd trust John Shiban about anything, so that's kind of novel *g*).

And how awesome was it that Dean knew all of the words to "Can't Fight This Feeling." Oh, Dean. ♥

[vaeltaa.livejournal.com]

That's exactly how I would rate the episodes, too. :D

[girlmostlikely.livejournal.com]

I love this show and I love everything you love and Ash is the most awesome new character ever and OMG, the bro!touching, Anne! I couldn't get enough of it, and there was so so sooo much to get enough of! *flails and dorks out*